Operations 8 min read

Is Accounts Payable a Liability? Yes. Here's the Catch

Is accounts payable a liability? Yes, a current one. See the 5 journal entries behind a parts invoice, and how one missed $85 core credit overstates it.

Is Accounts Payable a Liability? Yes. Here's the Catch
In this article
  1. Is accounts payable a liability? Yes, a current one
  2. Is accounts payable an asset or an expense?
  3. Is accounts payable a debit or a credit?
  4. The journal entries behind one parts invoice
  5. When accounts payable is a liability you don’t actually owe
  6. Accrued expenses vs. accounts payable
  7. Check your AP balance this month, by hand
  8. Your books record the debt. Nothing in them checks it.

Is accounts payable a liability? Yes. It’s a current liability: the money your shop owes vendors for parts and services you’ve already received but haven’t paid for yet.

If you want a gut check, watch a service manager’s face when the parts driver drops the month-end statement on the counter. Assets don’t get that look.

That’s the textbook answer, and it takes one sentence. The interesting part, for a repair shop, is that the number sitting in your accounts payable account is very often wrong. Usually too high. Sometimes too low. This post shows the journal entries and where the number drifts.

(Full disclosure: I run WickedFile, which checks parts invoices and credit memos against your repair orders so the balance you owe is the balance you actually owe. Everything below works with a spreadsheet first.)

Is accounts payable a liability? Yes, a current one

AccountingTools defines accounts payable as the aggregate amount of short-term obligations to pay suppliers for products and services purchased on credit. It’s recorded in a liability account.

It’s a current liability because vendor bills come due fast. Your parts suppliers might want payment within 30 days or by the statement due date. Anything due within a year lands in current liabilities on the balance sheet.

In a repair shop, accounts payable is mostly:

  • Parts invoices from your first-call stores, dealers, and tire suppliers.
  • Sublet invoices from the machine shop, the alignment guy, the glass company.
  • Shop supplies, uniforms, utilities, and the occasional equipment repair.

Anything you received on account and haven’t paid sits there.

Is accounts payable an asset or an expense?

Neither. This trips up a lot of owners, and it’s an easy one to fix.

Is accounts payable an asset? No. An asset is something you own or are owed. Payables are what you owe. The asset on the other side of the counter is accounts receivable: the fleet customer who hasn’t paid yet. (If you want the full side-by-side, see accounts payable vs. accounts receivable.)

Is accounts payable an expense? Also no, though they show up together. When a $400 brake parts invoice gets recorded, two things happen at once:

  • The cost goes to an expense account (or inventory, if it’s going on the shelf).
  • The obligation goes to accounts payable.

The expense says what you used. The payable says what you still owe. When you pay the bill, the payable goes down and cash goes down. The expense doesn’t move again.

Is accounts payable a debit or a credit?

Accounts payable has a credit balance, like every liability.

  • Credit AP when a bill comes in. You owe more.
  • Debit AP when you pay, or when a vendor credit memo comes in. You owe less.

That second bullet is the one that matters in auto repair. Payments aren’t the only thing that reduces AP. Credits do too, and a repair shop lives on credits: cores, returns, wrong parts, warranty.

The journal entries behind one parts invoice

Here’s a single alternator job from start to finish. Numbers are illustrative.

1. The invoice arrives. $1,240 total: $1,155 for the part and an $85 core charge, PO number matching RO 48211.

AccountDebitCredit
Parts cost of goods sold$1,240
Accounts payable$1,240

(Some shops book core charges to a separate core deposit account instead. Ask your accountant which way your books run. The AP side is identical either way.)

2. The core goes back and the vendor issues an $85 credit memo.

AccountDebitCredit
Accounts payable$85
Parts cost of goods sold$85

3. A wrong belt from the same order goes back. $62 credit memo.

AccountDebitCredit
Accounts payable$62
Parts cost of goods sold$62

4. You pay the statement. The vendor now shows $1,093 owed for this order.

AccountDebitCredit
Accounts payable$1,093
Cash$1,093

AP for this job is now zero. Clean. That’s how it’s supposed to work.

AccountingTools’ purchase returns example works the same way: when a supplier accepts a return and issues a credit, the buyer reduces its accounts payable liability. If you want the full mechanics of the document itself, I covered what a credit memo is and how to book it.

When accounts payable is a liability you don’t actually owe

Now run the same job the way it often goes in real life.

The core goes back on the parts run. Nobody writes it down. The vendor never issues the credit. Entry #2 never happens.

Your books still say you owe $1,178 for that order instead of $1,093. Your vendor’s statement says the same thing, because the vendor never processed the credit either. The two documents agree with each other. They’re both wrong.

That’s an overstated liability. And when you pay the statement, the overstatement stops being a bookkeeping problem and becomes $85 of real cash.

Here’s what a month of that can look like. Illustrative numbers for a busy single shop:

What went missingCountAvg. $AP overstated by
Core credits never issued9$70$630
Returns with a slip but no credit memo2$245$490
Total$1,120

Pay those statements as presented for a year and that’s $13,440 handed to your vendors, with every line of it posted correctly. Nothing in your accounting software looks wrong. It’s not designed to know.

It runs the other way too. A $430 phone order arrives, gets installed, and the invoice never makes it to the office. Now AP is understated by $430. So is your parts cost, which means last month’s profit looks $430 better than it was. Next month it shows up on the statement as “who ordered this?” and someone loses a Tuesday finding out.

I get why shops let this slide. Reconciling cores and credits is tedious, and the balance sheet doesn’t complain. It’s always easier to bury your head in the sand than reconcile your parts. But ignoring the gap doesn’t shrink it. It only guarantees you’ll never measure it.

For the deep version of the core problem, here’s where core charge money leaks.

Accrued expenses vs. accounts payable

These two get mixed up, and both are current liabilities, so it helps to know which is which.

Accounts payable comes from an invoice you actually have.

Accrued expenses are costs you’ve incurred but haven’t been billed for yet. AccountingTools’ accrued expenses entry lists goods received and consumed or sold without a supplier invoice as a standard example. Keep accruals out of the AP account itself. That account is for trade payables posted from actual vendor bills.

The repair shop version: parts arrive and get installed on October 31. The invoice shows up November 3. If you close October without it, October’s parts cost is too low and profit is too high.

The fix is an accrual at month end:

AccountDebitCredit
Parts cost of goods sold$430
Accrued expenses$430

It reverses on November 1. When the real invoice lands, it goes through AP like any other bill. This is one of the steps on a proper month-end close checklist.

Does any of this apply if you’re on cash basis?

Partly. Under the cash method, the IRS explains in Publication 538, you generally deduct expenses in the tax year you actually pay them. Under an accrual method, you deduct them in the year you incur them.

So a cash-basis shop may not see AP on its tax return. You still owe the money. The vendor still sends the statement. And a missing core credit still costs exactly $85 whichever method your accountant uses.

Check your AP balance this month, by hand

You don’t need software for a first pass. You need about two hours and one vendor.

  1. Pull your AP aging by vendor from QuickBooks or whatever you use.
  2. Pull that vendor’s latest statement. Compare the totals. Note the difference.
  3. List every core and return sent back in the last 60 days. Your return slips, the RO notes, the parts shelf.
  4. Match each one to a credit memo. No credit memo means the return isn’t finished. Call the vendor.
  5. List every part received but not yet invoiced. Those are accruals at month end.
  6. Fix the entries before you pay. Paying first and arguing later is how $85 becomes “eh, not worth the call.”

Start with your biggest parts vendor. If you want the full statement workflow, here’s how to reconcile a vendor statement. And if QuickBooks is where the entries live, these QuickBooks practices for repair shops keep the AP side honest.

Your books record the debt. Nothing in them checks it.

QuickBooks will total your accounts payable perfectly. It has no way to know that a core went back on Tuesday and the vendor never credited it. That’s the gap WickedFile was built for.

What it reads: your vendor invoices, credit memos, and statements. It also pulls repair orders from your shop management system, entries from QuickBooks Online, and bank and card transactions through Plaid.

What it flags for this topic:

  • Core charges with no matching core credit, which overstate AP.
  • Returns with no credit memo, and credits issued but not applied on the statement.
  • Statement lines with no supporting invoice, and card or bank payments with no invoice behind them.
  • Invoices with no related accounting entry, which understate AP.
  • Parts bought for a repair order but never sold on it.

How to use the free trial here: you get 500 scanned pages, no credit card. Upload last month’s invoices, credit memos, and statements from your two biggest parts vendors, and connect your shop management system. Then compare what WickedFile says you owe against what the statement says you owe. The difference is your overstatement, line by line.

What it doesn’t do: it isn’t your accounting system, it doesn’t replace your bookkeeper or CPA, and it isn’t a payment processor. It won’t post journal entries or pay vendors for you. After the trial, the Grow plan is $299 a month, flat. If you run one vendor and track every core on a clipboard that actually works, you may not need it.

Check last month’s statements in the free trial →

Accounts payable is a liability. It just shouldn’t be a bigger one than you actually owe. Reconcile it, and the only thing overstated on your balance sheet will be how much you enjoyed reading about journal entries.

Frequently asked questions

Is accounts payable a liability?

Yes. Accounts payable is a current liability: the total your business owes suppliers for goods and services bought on credit and not yet paid. It sits in the current liabilities section of the balance sheet because vendor bills are normally due within weeks, well inside a year.

Is accounts payable a debit or a credit?

Accounts payable carries a credit balance. You credit it when a vendor bill comes in, which increases what you owe, and you debit it when you pay the bill or receive a vendor credit memo, which reduces what you owe.

Is accounts payable an asset?

No. Accounts payable is money you owe, so it is a liability. The asset is accounts receivable, which is money customers owe you. For a repair shop, a parts invoice you haven't paid is payable; a fleet customer's open repair order balance is receivable.

Is accounts payable an expense?

No, although the two are connected. When a parts invoice is recorded, the cost goes to an expense or inventory account and the amount owed goes to accounts payable. The expense measures what you used. The payable measures what you still owe. Paying the bill reduces the payable and your cash, not your expenses.

What is the difference between accrued expenses and accounts payable?

Accounts payable comes from vendor invoices you have actually received. Accrued expenses are estimated liabilities for costs you incurred but haven't been billed for yet, such as parts delivered on the last day of the month whose invoice arrives in the next month. Both are current liabilities, but they sit in separate accounts.

Can software check whether my accounts payable balance is right?

Accounting software only totals what was entered. WickedFile, which I run, reads your parts invoices, credit memos, and statements and matches them to repair orders and QuickBooks Online, flagging missing core credits, uncredited returns, and invoices that never got entered. It doesn't replace your bookkeeper or pay vendors. The free trial covers 500 scanned pages with no credit card.

Prove your AP balance before you pay it

WickedFile matches parts invoices, credit memos, and statements to your repair orders, so uncredited cores and missing returns don't inflate what you owe.

Start the free trial
500 free pages · No credit card · Connects to your SMS